How humans and technology conspired to spoil the World Cup Final


Goal-line technology — available in tennis since the turn of the century — finally meant that all the goals scored would actually count.

Moreover, the Video Assistant Referee was there to make sure that referees on the pitch blew their whistles in the right direction.

Mostly, it worked. Except, that is, when it came to Sunday’s final.

The greatest World Cup Final referees are the ones you never notice. They let the game flow and, when they have to make a call, they make the right one.

Surely, this time Argentinian referee Nestor Pitana would be papally infallible.

Not only was he greatly experienced, but he had the blissful backup of technological help — an Italian referee staring at multiple screens in a small Russian room, ready to warn him of things he might have missed.

How woefully it all worked.

In the first half, Croatia was by far the better team.

Yet, in the 18th minute France launched a rare foray forward and French striker Antoine Griezmann cheated.

There’s no more appropriate word for it.

He sought out an opponent’s foot and attempted to deliberately trip over it.

This was a moment when technology could have helped.

One whisper from the video referee to the one on the field would have told him that Griezmann deserved a yellow card.

Instead, the referee on the field gave France a free-kick — the previous action was deemed not reviewable, according to the current rules — from which a goal ensued.

It got worse.

Croatia got back into the game and scored a wonderful goal.

It might have had a couple more.


And then, near the end of the the first half, the ball came across, France’s Blaise Matuidi mis-headed it and it hit the hand of Croatian striker Ivan Perisic.

Perisic has his hands in a perfectly normal position. The referee decided there was no foul, yet the French players started whining.

And then the video referee asked Pitana to take a look at the replay.

For all the world (well, me), this was no penalty. The criterion for handball is that it’s supposed to be deliberate. Perisic didn’t have time to do anything but let the ball hit his hand.

It is, for sure, a gray area in soccer, but technology is supposed to turn that gray to black-and-white. Or at least a much more defined shade of gray.

The problem, however, was that Pitana being alerted to watch it again (and again) — rather than being told one way or the other what the decision was — told him that he might have made a mistake.

Already, he was in troubling territory. Then he had to watch the replay in front of all the world, with French players and fans shrieking in his ears.